diff --git a/borgmatic/commands/borgmatic.py b/borgmatic/commands/borgmatic.py
index d346662..c1f58ec 100644
--- a/borgmatic/commands/borgmatic.py
+++ b/borgmatic/commands/borgmatic.py
@@ -404,7 +404,11 @@ def collect_configuration_run_summary_logs(config_filenames, args):
             yield logging.makeLogRecord(dict(levelno=logging.CRITICAL, msg=error))
 
     if args.extract:
-        validate.guard_configuration_contains_repository(args.repository, configs)
+        try:
+            validate.guard_configuration_contains_repository(args.repository, configs)
+        except ValueError as error:
+            yield logging.makeLogRecord(dict(levelno=logging.CRITICAL, msg=error))
+            return
 
     for config_filename, config in configs.items():
         try:
diff --git a/tests/unit/commands/test_borgmatic.py b/tests/unit/commands/test_borgmatic.py
index 59d879f..5a656f4 100644
--- a/tests/unit/commands/test_borgmatic.py
+++ b/tests/unit/commands/test_borgmatic.py
@@ -57,7 +57,7 @@ def test_collect_configuration_run_summary_logs_info_for_success():
     assert any(log for log in logs if log.levelno == module.logging.INFO)
 
 
-def test_collect_configuration_run_summary_still_succeeds_when_extract_true():
+def test_collect_configuration_run_summary_logs_info_for_success_with_extract():
     flexmock(module.validate).should_receive('parse_configuration').and_return({'test.yaml': {}})
     flexmock(module.validate).should_receive('guard_configuration_contains_repository')
     flexmock(module).should_receive('run_configuration')
@@ -68,6 +68,18 @@ def test_collect_configuration_run_summary_still_succeeds_when_extract_true():
     assert any(log for log in logs if log.levelno == module.logging.INFO)
 
 
+def test_collect_configuration_run_summary_logs_critical_for_extract_with_repository_error():
+    flexmock(module.validate).should_receive('parse_configuration').and_return({'test.yaml': {}})
+    flexmock(module.validate).should_receive('guard_configuration_contains_repository').and_raise(
+        ValueError
+    )
+    args = flexmock(extract=True, repository='repo')
+
+    logs = tuple(module.collect_configuration_run_summary_logs(('test.yaml',), args=args))
+
+    assert any(log for log in logs if log.levelno == module.logging.CRITICAL)
+
+
 def test_collect_configuration_run_summary_logs_critical_for_parse_error():
     flexmock(module.validate).should_receive('parse_configuration').and_raise(ValueError)
     args = flexmock(extract=False)